Some readers may want to toss a verbal rotten tomato at the second part of that headline, given stubbornly weak metals prices, but let's see if the data we've uncovered below will lower that cocked arm…
As of last Friday, silver is down 26.6% on the year, and down a whopping 55% since its $48.70 high on April 28, 2011. The bear market cycle is now two and a half years old—and no one can say with absolute certainty that the bottom is in.
Sounds like an investment to avoid.
For now, let's ignore the fundamental argument for silver—an alternative currency that, like gold, will sooner or later respond to the historic levels of currency dilution throughout much of the developed world—and consider the behavior of investors. In response to the price drubbing, have they abandoned the silver market? If that were so, it might be a warning sign that we've overstayed our welcome.
Silver on Trial
If I were on trial for claiming the bull market were alive and well, here are some of the exhibits I would present to the court…
Exhibit #1: SLV Holders Defy GLD Sellers
"Your honor, I first present the following chart. Check out the metal holdings of SLV (iShares Silver Trust) vs. GLD (SPDR Gold Trust) year-to-date."
Very curious. SLV is down 28.1% YTD, and was off as much as 39% on June 27. Normally, you'd expect to see significant outflows of metal from the fund in such a downdraft—but that didn't happen, in spite of the exodus that did occur in the major gold ETF, GLD.
To be sure, there are some ownership differences between the two funds. For example, institutional investors comprise roughly 40% of GLD, but only 14% of SLV.
However, if the bull market in precious metals were over, one would think both funds would see massive selling and outflow of metal from the crash in prices. That hasn't happened, and this lack of selling by retail and even institutional investors shows just how confident they are in the long-term prospects for the metal.
Some investors may be buying silver because they believe the economy is improving, since roughly half of silver's use is industrial. But the low fluctuation in fund holdings implies the make-up of investors hasn't shifted that much—i.e., most of the investors that bought earlier for monetary reasons remain invested. If they believed those selling their GLD shares were correct, they'd be selling their silver too. They're not.
Exhibit #2: India Defies Gold Restrictions and Loads Up on Silver
"Your honor, the data coming out of India regarding silver imports demand attention. Here's the picture since 2008."
Through August of this year, India has imported 128.6 million ounces (Moz) of silver, more than double the 61 Moz brought into the country in all of 2012. Put another way, in just eight months, Indians have already imported 16% of the 787 Moz of silver mined globally in 2012.
There are strong reasons to believe the trend will continue…
- The Diwali festival, one of the most favorable events for purchasing precious metals jewelry and gifts, gets under way in early November
- A strong monsoon season boosted agricultural harvests this year, increasing disposable incomes
It is thus reasonable to suggest that India will import more than 20% of last year's total worldwide silver production, and that imports will exceed 2008's record year of 161.6 Moz.
It's true that some of the jump in silver demand is a result of the anti-gold steps taken by the Indian government. Their interventions have squeezed supplies and made gold more expensive and more difficult to obtain—and some citizens have naturally turned to silver as a substitute.
It's for this reason that many analysts expect India to continue on this torrid pace of silver imports over the coming years.
Exhibit #3: Bullion Buyers Defy ETF Sellers
"Last, your honor, bullion investors see ongoing concerns about the fiscal and monetary state of many developed countries and in response to weak bullion prices have stepped up their silver purchases."
Here's a chart of the annual sales of American silver Eagles from the US Mint since 2008. The data for 2013 are through October 16.
The US Mint has sold 37.7 million silver Eagles so far this year, an amount that already exceeds all of 2012 by 10%. It's just 7% below 2011's record year, so, like Indian silver imports, we'll almost certainly see a new record by year-end.
Notice also how sales increased in response to the price crash this year. Why would investors buy more metal when the price was halved? Only if they believed there were very strong reasons it would go back up.
The Royal Canadian Mint reported that "year-to-date, we've had record volume for silver Maple Leafs, the greatest we've had in the over 25 years that we've produced them." This is interesting, the spokesperson added, because "the Northern Hemisphere summer is traditionally a slow time for coin and metal sales, but that's not the case this year."
"Your honor, the evidence clearly suggests that the bull market in precious metals is far from over—in spite of the mainstream media ignoring the strong trends underpinning this market. If it were time to exit this industry, we wouldn't see SLV holders refusing to sell, Indians buying record amounts of silver, and retail investors hoarding silver bullion at historic levels.
"As a final piece of evidence, your honor, we even arranged for a generous discount from one of our recommended bullion dealers on silver Maple Leafs—a discount you won't find anywhere else. Just sign up for a risk-free trial subscription to BIG GOLD, and you may be able to pay for your subscription from the savings.
"The silver price has not responded to this undercurrent of activity yet, but the ongoing stampede for silver clearly signals many investors around the world believe there is strong reason to continue buying precious metals."
I look up and see the judge smile. She asks, "What's the name of that dealer, Mr. Clark?"